All of us
ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS
The language of our conventional economy is what rules politics and our society. Increases in the GNP are good for any government's image. We know, though, that Macroeconomic Accounting overlooks the loss of natural (and cultural) heritage and does not take into account the damage produced by economic growth. We can see, in Catalonia, the considerable loss of agricultural land and countryside around Barcelona as a result of the city's uncontrolled growth. This is not subtracted from increases in the GNP. If noise increases or rivers get dirty, we do not subtract anything from the Gross National Product. On the other hand, the cost of mitigating or correcting this (acoustic screens or treatment plants) is added to the GNP. Economics has got its sums wrong.

To put this right, there could be a change in taxation. But there are also other ways: agreements with business; a change in society's consumer habits and state or local agreements with aware consumers, and particularly the fight by environmentalists against pollution. I myself have frequently written on the Ecology of the Poor and the Movement for Environmental Justice in the United States.

There is also talk of changes in taxation. More environmental taxes to make up for smaller social revenues. There is room for discussion. There should, at least, as regards inputs into the economy, be a tax on the loss of "natural capital" (in particular, countries exporting wood, oil, minerals and metals should pay). As regards undesirable outputs --for example, pollution--, there should be taxes like the European eco-tax on carbon dioxide emissions which has been talked about for almost ten years.

These taxes would not result in "ecologically correct" prices that measured future, uncertain and irreversible damage. They would, however, result in ecologically corrected prices, better than current prices, which are leading the economy in an anti-ecological direction.

Joan Martinez Alier
Board member of the ISEE
Department of Economics and Economic History
Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona
Edifici B
08193 Bellaterra (Barcelona)
Spain
Tel.: +34 - 93 581 1282 (office)
+34 - 93 581 1200 (secretary)
Fax: +34 - 93 581 2012
e-mail: IEHE6@CC.UAB.ES or alier@cc.uab.es




If you want to subscribe to All of us, write your e-mail address on the next box, choose "in" and push the "send" button.

If you want to cancel your subscription to the magazine All of us, write your e-mail address on the next box, choose "out" and push the "send" button.

  In Out